What if speech doesn’t happen?

Perhaps you have skipped to this section first, out of curiosity. Perhaps you have skipped to this section first, because your child is 12, and you are grounded in reality. Or perhaps you are here now after having read all the other sections — in which case, I salute your tenacity.

This section — indeed, this whole guide — wades into treacherous territory because we are supposed to be okay with the idea that some children will never talk, accept it, and support it the best we can. Access to communication is a universal right. This practically translates into providing access to robust high-tech AAC at the earliest ages. The section should be titled something hopeful like “Speech May Not Happen, And That’s Okay.”

This way of thinking is a reaction to a sad historical reality — speech has been put on a pedestal for so long that it has resulted in many children stunted in their ability to communicate, by any means. Deaf children whose parents and teachers favored the development of speech (the “oralism” of Alexander Graham Bell) were denied exposure to sign language during critical developmental periods, with devastating consequences. Today, autistic children often have parents who refuse to teach them sign language, or PECS, or how to use a speech-generating device, out of fear it will impede speech. So there is the well-founded fear that promoting natural speech promotes ableism, inflames prejudices against other communication modalities, and makes those who rely on other methods to communicate seem “less than.”

In this context, a child carrying a tablet to talk is not just using a device. They are overcoming significant societal fears and prejudice.

So I understand how all this gets touchy. But you will notice that in all previous sections, I’ve promoted heavily the acceptance of all ways to communicate. I’ve promoted learning gestures and AAC, on the grounds that it helps develop language, and eventually speech. Against this charged emotional backdrop, I hope I have earned enough trust with you to offer a few careful facts.

Looking beyond high-tech robust AAC

Natural speech is a much better way to communicate than high-tech robust AAC (which I will henceforth refer to as “AAC”). Natural speech is more flexible and less constrained. You can say "fairies danced across the stage” just as easily as you can say “I want an apple, please.” AAC is 10 times slower, and its users say 100 times fewer words per day.

When parents balk at AAC, it is not just out of fear or prejudice. It is a severely limited way to communicate. It has a (relatively) low floor, but a low ceiling too.

That is why the intent of Visual Choices is not to be a long-term solution to communicate. It is meant to be a teaching tool to get to speech, or an equivalent alternative.

What alternatives? There are communication methods that are just as fast and flexible as talking. They are hardly ever considered for nonverbal autistic children. They are sign language and typing.

The case for sign language

Why no love for sign language? Mainly because it is considered hard to teach, and it limits your child’s communication partners. For AAC, it can be anyone. For sign language, it must be someone who knows sign language. And it is considered hard to teach because most therapists do not know sign language. They know a few signs, but they do not know sign language.

But these considerations hardly stop parents of deaf children. Even if the parents don’t know sign language, there are Deaf schools, Deaf teachers, and Deaf tutors. It is considered an emergency to fill the child’s world with signs before critical windows for language growth close.

And imagine the benefits to a child who has strong language, and no speech, but who can sign fluently. They can express any thought they like just as fast as talking. They can plug into an existing community of people who sign. Think of it this way — is it better to talk minimally to everyone? or to talk fluently to a core group of people who get you? (that is the autistic experience, by the way, verbal or not).

I talked once with a small group where an AAC specialist and a Deaf educator were both present. The specialist acknowledged that many autistic children could become fluent in sign language — but that the restrictions in communicative partners would be too severe for this to be worthwhile. What if, I hypothesized, an AI technology existed that could turn their signs into speech recognizable by anyone? Would that be better than current AAC? Yes, she said immediately. That would be much better than current AAC.

Such technologies may not be so far off.

The case for typing

Tying is another option. I’ve already mentioned in the apraxia section an 11 year nonverbal autistic child who taught himself to type through his special interest in numbers and letters.

And there’s another example of a nonverbal autistic child learning typing. His mom contacted me in response to an email I sent about an app update. She wrote, “It’s actually so much better if you teach your child to type. Kids with autism are so smart regardless of popular belief and if you teach them the keyboard and how to communicate through typing, it’s just so much better [than AAC].”

Of course, I had to know more. I wrote back, and she replied with pages of details. Her son is 16 years old. He used to talk and had an extensive vocabulary, but he suffered a regression and lost “every word he once spoke, along with milestones like pointing, raising his hands to be picked up, running to the door when dad got home from work, eye contact, playing normally with toys, etc.” He was diagnosed at 22 months, and started round-the-clock ABA, speech therapy, and occupational therapy.

Starting when he was 6 years old, the mom homeschooled him along with his younger sister, teaching them both the alphabet and letters, reading and writing. There was no special interest in numbers and letters. This was persistent systematic instruction — and rather one-sided. Everything was hand-over-hand. There was no expression back for 5 years. Imagine what was needed to continue teaching this way day after day.

Then one day, she felt her son’s hand move under hers, and she realized he was trying to write simple numbers (1-5) back on a math worksheet. The mom returned to the public school excitedly to tell them what her son was now capable of. They claimed she was wrong, that his cognition was at a very low level, and that it was all facilitated — all the expressive output was coming from her, not her child. She was crushed.

So she decided to teach him a way to communicate that was 100% unequivocally his own. Her son could point to simple printed pictures, but never took to high tech AAC. She began to teach him to type. Writing required overcoming all sorts of fine motor challenges, but typing was simpler — the same letters in the same consistent location every time. Now, at 16 years old, her son can type single words to let her know what he wants, completely unassisted. She wishes she would have started him at age 6, so he would be more fluent now.

As for difficulty, she acknowledges that typing “takes focus, memorization, eye coordination, and fine motor control. But he’s typing and it’s getting better.” In contrast, she says “I’ll tell you the effort it takes for someone with autism to visually search for the buttons in AAC is as frustrating as them searching for letters to spell words, and AAC is a lot less effective in communicative expression. AAC lacks the why.”

So that’s where it stands. Two parents of nonverbal autistic children who learned typing late in life, one through a special interest, and the other through a mom who never gave up. And now it is a primary way to communicate — no facilitation, no guiding, no choices, no restrictions, no division into core or fringe, or “home page” versus “one folder deep” versus “two folders deep and a next button” — just a free and clear window into their beautiful, independent mind.

There must be more cases like this. I don’t run an autism center, I’m not a therapist, I’m just an app developer and a parent. Yet I learned about these two children who could communicate through typing.

Facilitated teaching is okay, facilitated communication is not

I can only begin to understand the feeling that your child has more going on inside them than they are capable of expressing, and the desire to help bring that out. I also understand that low expressive ability is often explained away as low cognitive ability, as if to justify low expectations and less effort on teaching, not more. That is always wrong. Everyone can learn. Low cognition (if that is the case) means more repetitions and more effort to teach is needed, not less.

Facilitation is okay. Physical prompting is facilitation. Limiting a grid to a field of 2 choices is facilitation. But when facilitation is kept around so long that it turns from a teaching method into a form of communication — that is bad. Because it freezes learning. Because it becomes all too easy to override any flicker of agency your child has. Because facilitation, like any support, must fade away so that your child can grow.

A place for high tech AAC?

So is there a place for high tech AAC systems?

Yes — but I don’t think it’s as broad as generally believed.

If your child has weak language skills, traditional high-tech robust AAC is not the best way to develop them. It requires too much navigation to jump between different parts of speech, and all the fun verbs and nouns are consigned to fringe folders. Visual Choices is designed differently to promote language learning. Working on gestures and play is critical.

If your child has strong language skills, they will likely start talking on their own, given some encouragement. If this does not happen, they’ll need to have some other way to get speech out. If they can learn a motor plan for high-tech AAC, why not have them learn a motor plan for sign language or typing instead?

Maybe it’s too hard to teach. But given the difference in communication efficiency between sign language or typing versus AAC, it’s definitely worth trying. The juice is worth the squeeze.

But what if it’s really too hard? Then the ideal high-tech AAC user becomes a specific case — strong language skills but very limited motor skills — rather than the default assumption for all nonverbal children.

There is another app we have developed called Face Talk, which makes typing possible using a 2x2 grid.

Interface of an app called Face Talk, showing letters accessible via nested 2x2 grids, along with the partially completed sentence: 'the best way to predict the future is to create ...'

But if that doesn’t work, then yes. Robust high-tech AAC can be valuable and life-changing. But it does have the limitations mentioned earlier.

Beyond the monoculture

You have choices.

It may not feel like it. The introduction of the iPad in 2010 democratized access to communication. Now, families no longer needed to spend years working with therapists and insurance companies to get a ten thousand dollar device. They could just buy an iPad, download an app, and be tapping on talking picture tiles within minutes.

Some nonverbal autistic children saw benefits right away. But many others did not. If they did not, there wasn’t much more they could try. Because at the end of the day, these apps all looked and functioned in a similar way. There was a monoculture of apps.

I wasn’t sure Visual Choices AAC was a worthwhile app to develop. I was told AAC was a solved problem, and that the world did not need one more AAC app.

But when we released the app, and saw the response from parents, we realized how wrong that opinion was.

Parents were hungry for choices.

Rest assured, you are not the only family that feels left behind by the AAC revolution.

Many children do not take to it. Many children fail to develop functional communication. Many children fail to develop language. Many children fall into a holding pattern, with limited progress for years.

The apps do not get blamed. The teaching methods do not get blamed. Children get blamed — maybe their cognition is too low, or their motor skills too poor. Parents get blamed — maybe they’re not modeling enough at home.

But the real problem is that many AAC specialists are doing the same thing. Children are given as large of a grid (preserve motor planning) as at early of an age (presume competence) as possible. If the child doesn’t respond to this, direct physical guidance is eschewed (honoring autonomy) — instead the default teaching method is aided language modeling (even for children with limited joint attention and imitation skills), first with expectation, then without expectation, when progress stalls.

The children who fail remain silent. The ones who succeed make their presence known on social media. Parents of children who “don’t take to AAC” are left to wonder, is it just us?

No. It is not.

We all have different ways we like to do things. Of course we do. We’re human. That’s what makes us interesting. That’s what makes us unique. But we also like to be around people who agree with us. The result is that any time an issue elevates to the level of group importance, you get factions. Tribes. Ideologies.

As a parent, you cannot afford the luxury of ideology. You need to do what works best for your child. It can be frustrating to interact with professionals who can afford to hold on to an ideology because they see so many children — if some respond to their method, great! if they do not, moving on! Good professionals can tailor their approach to the child. But let’s be honest, you quickly run into the limits of how far they’re willing to stretch.

The problem is that high-tech AAC technology has evolved to such complexity that it falls to specialists to implement. The specialists out of necessity have developed an ideology centered around technology. This ideology squeezes out consideration of other critical developmental components needed for AAC to be effective. There is too much talk of grid sizes, vocabulary selection, folder organization, core versus fringe, and color coding; and too little talk of play, gestures, and language.

If autism was a speech generating disorder, the introduction of a speech generating device would be a complete solution — just swap out the mouth for a tablet, and get the motor plan plugged in. But autism is not primarily a speech generating disorder. It is a social deficit that requires social interventions to address, leading to a language delay that requires language interventions to resolve.

Zooming out from the technology makes other choices evident.

If your child is not making progress with requesting, they can work on gestures. If they’re stuck on gestures, they can work on play. If naturalistic instruction isn’t working, explicit instruction might. Sign language is possible. Different behavioral strategies can be used. Music might offer a way in. So might letters and literacy.

Few professionals can hop between ideologies so readily. But as a parent, you can and you must.

Anything has got to be better than tapping on a grid over and over again, with no response from your child.

You don’t have to settle for that. Your child can learn. They can learn to point, so they can share their interests with you in the most basic way. They can learn to play, so they can share their world with you. They can learn language, so they have something to say.

Their mouth may begin to produce flexible speech. If it comes out garbled or inconsistent, they may be able to tolerate apraxia therapy. If not, they may be able to learn how to move their mouth on their own through visual phonics and visual/auditory/temporal models. And if the words still don’t come out, they can learn sign language (which builds joint attention, and can also boost the ability to talk) or typing (which builds literacy).

Visual Choices AAC is not just a choice board app. It is a choices app. It provides you and your child with choices. If one thing doesn’t work, you can try another.

I have no fixed ideology. I am purely pragmatic. I want your child to grow. As a company, we only grow if your child does too. Best wishes for your child's future success!