“You can’t make a turtle come out
You can’t make a turtle come out
You can call him or coax him or shake him or shout
But you can’t make a turtle come out, come out
You can’t make a turtle come out.”
So you’ll have to patiently wait
So you’ll have to patiently wait
And when he gets ready, he’ll open the gate.
But you can’t make a turtle come out, come out
You can’t make a turtle come out.”
— “You Can’t Make a Turtle Come Out”, Malvina Reynolds
Well-meaning parents often try to coax speech from their reluctant child by prodding them with questions (e.g. “what do you want?”) or telling them what to say (e.g. “say ball”).
Like the proverbial turtle, the child withdraws, and the parent discovers what generations of parents and therapists before them have found — the more you push a child to talk, the less they want to do it.
So what’s a parent to do? Watch and wait? Sit and hope?
Yes — but strategically.
The clinical guides sound pleasant enough, “Here are a list of communication temptations to use with your child ...”
But let’s call a spade a spade. They’re asking you to be a bit of a dick to your child. Think of the ways an older sibling might aggravate a younger sibling, and you’re on the right track (siblings are, in fact, famously good at getting each other to talk).
Make eye contact with your child, then eat a snack off their plate (“no! mine!”). Walk together to a door, then do nothing (“open!”).
Toys are now out of reach (“help!” or “up!”) or in closed containers (“open!”). So is food. Snack portions are smaller (“more!”).
Right after an enticing demonstration, bubble juice containers close, wind-up toys unwind, and balloons deflate (“help!” or “more!”)
Once you’ve set up the situation, look directly into your child’s eyes and pause. Wait. Count to 3. Count to 5 if you can manage it. Bite your tongue if you have to. The expectant pause is the hardest part, because you really want to fill the silence with words of your own. Resist the temptation. Let your child fill the silence. If they won’t, model what you want them to say in a bright and sing-songy voice (“o-pen!”) But give them a real chance to talk first. Don’t rush. Be relaxed and nonchalant.
And when it works, and your child speaks up, your enthusiastic response matters. Light up. Immediately give them what they asked for. Make it feel good to communicate.
You are teasing your child, tempting them to talk. Obviously they may not like it. Pick your battles. When my child was young, giving him less food wouldn’t have resulted in him saying “more!” It would have resulted in him not eating. Having him ask me to open doors and toy bins proved to be more successful. You know what works best for your child — try things out, but also follow your instincts.
Other strategies are gentler and you may feel better about doing them. I already talked about sensory social routines in “Find Out What Your Child Wants.” Choices are also powerful, and a situation where asking a question to your child is acceptable (e.g. “which one do you want, red or blue?”)
Cloze language is fun. That’s when you say every part of a sentence except the last word, and you wait for your child to chime in:
You can do this with books too. My son loved the book “Jet Plane” by Macaulay, and wanted me to read it to him over and over again. One day I went to his speech therapist, and demonstrated that he could say some big words now:
She let me know that he couldn’t really read (I knew that!) and that it wasn’t functional communication (so what?) But I didn’t care. I was so proud.
Declarative language is another helpful practice. If questions and commands are now forbidden, what is allowed? Simple statements of your thoughts, feelings, and observations. One trick is to add “I wonder” to turn your questions into statements:
You can also preface commands with “let’s” to turn them into statements:
This is a method that remains useful even after your child is fully talking:
It works by removing pressure from a conversation. Adults do this naturally when they talk with other adults. Have you ever been in a conversation that felt more like an interrogation or an interview? Uncomfortable, right? Adults naturally soften the edges of their curiosity by making generous statements and observations to each other. Treating our children — yes, even toddlers — with the same courtesy gives them the comfort to peek out of their shell, and feel confident adding their words to the world, until one day they are full conversational partners with us.
On the technical side, Visual Choices has an “expectant pause” setting that introduces a time delay between when a child presses a picture tile, and when the app speaks. Setting it to a few seconds gives your child a chance to talk first, before the system does it for them.
A few extra tips. Observe your child. Be attuned to them. Look at what they are doing, and listen to what they are trying to say. Don’t anticipate their needs by doing things automatically for them. But if they give any indication, however slight, that they want you to do something, do it. Respond enthusiastically, and reward all attempts at communication.
Sometimes parents decide that to encourage speech, they will only respond to talking. nothing else. Not to hand leading, not to signs, not to pointing, not to shared glances, not to grunts. Only talking. This usually leads to the child shutting down and withdrawing in protest. Now they don’t have talking, and they don’t have signs either. Be patient. Every form of communication is a valuable cobblestone on the road to speech.
When you do talk to your child, it’s good to use short 1-2 word phrases delivered in a bright, drawn out, sing-songy fashion. You want to be easy to imitate. I’ll admit that I hedged my bets by sprinkling in long complex sentences as well, on the off-chance my son could understand them.
One time, I took my son to a history museum, and watched a mom interact in a very speech therapy way with her daughter (“UP heeee-re!”, “biiiig caar”, “reeed ph-ONE!”). My heart skipped a beat. She’s one of us, I thought! Then she started yelling at my son for not sharing a toy with her daughter. It was a nice moment while it lasted, anyway.
Finally, if your child is fortunate enough to have speech therapy, always sit in on the sessions. The reason is simple. Speech therapy is really parent training. They only see your child 1 to 2 hours per week. You see your child 50 to 100 hours per week. The only way their speech improves is if you are doing what they are doing too.
When I first attended speech sessions with my son, I was amazed at the therapist’s stamina. She was so engaging, so responsive, so playful. I couldn’t imagine doing it for 5 minutes, let alone 60.
Two weeks later, I was like this is the same old, same old. Two months later, I was thinking, this is all the stuff I already do with him at home. And then I realized, that was the point!
I know it’s hard to catch a break, and when you have a wonderful therapist engaging your child in play, it’s tempting to bow out and get some time for yourself. But don’t do it during speech. Save it for ABA. (Kidding! Just kidding. But one of them is MANY more hours than the other).
If you’ve tried everything without success and landed here, take a deep breath. This is a controversial topic with limited scientific consensus.
Here’s what everyone agrees on. Autistic children often have trouble with coordinated moving. They may struggle to stand or walk. They may have trouble clapping or grabbing. Sequences of motion (“praxis”) like eating with a fork may be especially hard.
Talking is all of the above times one hundred. To talk, your jaw, lips, tongue, and vocal cords have to move quickly between positions in a precise and coordinated way. And certainly, speech therapists see autistic children who jumble their sounds, have trouble with consonants, or have choppy or robotic speech.
The controversial part is if an autistic child is not talking, is it a language delay (very common)? apraxia (maybe)? or both (who knows)?
Apraxia in adults usually comes from damage to a particular part of the brain. But in autistic children, that part of the brain looks fine, and there’s more of a hand wave toward .... well, because autism.
The even bigger challenge is that if a child isn’t talking at all, it’s exceedingly difficult to tell if they have apraxia because the sounds they produce are so far from speech. Is their apraxia so severe that it’s making speech production impossible? Or is it an extreme language delay? There have been claims and counter-claims of over and underdiagnosis.
The scientific debate is fascinating, but I’m sure you want to know what this has to do with your child. So let me give it to you straight.
Try everything else first. Work on play, work on gestures, work on AAC. Encourage speech. If at the end of all this, you have a child that is motivated to talk but has garbled and inconsistent speech, they may have an apraxia issue. Your child’s speech therapist will make a referral, and the specialist will tell you.
And then you’re going to be in a difficult position, because the standard treatment for apraxia is invasive and annoying to the child. It is not blowing bubbles and racing toy cars, like regular speech therapy. It’s having a therapist touch your mouth, lips, and jaw over and over again. It’s saying pieces of words repeatedly while being subjected to correction. Speech is not encouraged, it is demanded. It is not something parents can do themselves at home. A specialist needs to see your child three to five times per week, and your child will need to do ~100 trials per session. Few autistic children can tolerate apraxia therapy.
A prominent apraxia therapist told me that for autistic kids she sees, it’s a straight referral to AAC. And this may be okay. If your child has strong language skills, they will not be a typical AAC user limited to single word requesting. They will be able to produce sentences.
Is there a middle ground? Something that isn’t full apraxia therapy, but could still be helpful?
Nothing proven.
The best modern therapies for childhood apraxia of speech include methods like dynamic temporal and tactile cuing (DTTC) and integrated phonological awareness (IPA). DTTC focuses on breaking words down into phonemes, and using auditory, visual, tactile, and temporal cues to help your child understand how to move their lips, jaw, and tongue. IPA is based on letter recognition and phonics. The printed materials used to implement these methods cost thousands of dollars, still less than the cost of the specialized training needed to implement them.
And yet ...
What if it’s less about teaching them how to move their mouth, and more about surrounding them with good visual/auditory/temporal models, providing encouragement, then letting them figure it out themselves?
Because here is what is known. Nonverbal autistic children sometimes learn how to read on their own. I knew an 11 year old nonverbal autistic child whose special interest was numbers and letters. He never developed speech or language. But he could type — unassisted — lists of where he wanted to go that day. Target. Vons. Boomers. He cracked the code himself.
Language therapy for autistic children requires other people, because the core impairment being addressed is social communication. You improve the social part to improve the communication part.
But apraxia therapy is different. It is precise. Repetitive. Technical. Demanding. The kind of experience an autistic child could not tolerate being subjected to, but might subject themselves to, if it caught their interest.
Here are more stories.
Visual Choices has included from the start a simple visual model of talking. Tap a tile, and it becomes like Pac Man, the top and bottom halves pivoting and chattering away in sync with the talking. We added this feature after reading an eye tracking study indicating that autistic children were particularly attentive to sound/motion synchrony. And it seems like this visualization does capture the attention of autistic children reliably. A 13 year old nonverbal autistic child played the animations over and over. A 7 year old nonverbal autistic child in Kasari’s lab did the same, and started vocalizing soon after (in the context of JASPER therapy). This happened many times with many children. These are anecdotes, not data. But we can get autistic children to like looking at moving mouths, by making the experience simple, repetitive, and predictable (and far removed from unpredictable and overwhelming human eyes).
We’ve also added sound reactive animation to motivate speech. The child makes any kind of sound, and the computer mouth moves up and down in synchrony. This feature is automatically enabled during the expectant pause period. It conveys a simple message — look! You’re making something happen here. This is fun! The function was cribbed from the popular Bla Bla Bla app, which has dozens of therapists and teachers mentioning how motivating it has been for speech production.
And finally the big guns — visual phonics. Words are automatically broken down into phonemes, with accompanying pictures of the lips and teeth, as well as side animations of how the lips, jaw, and tongue work together to talk. Tap phonemes, and watch them change position.
There are limitations. The visuals don’t show the movement from one phoneme to the next. Technically, it shows articulation, not praxis. Even if your child learns how to pronounce individual phonemes correctly, they are still faced with the formidable task of blending them together into words. Blending is hard to learn, even for typically developing children. A lot of reading instruction is about phonemic awareness and blending. I taught my son how to blend sounds in the course of teaching him to read. Blending took him a few weeks to learn. But he is verbal, and doesn’t have apraxia. Your mileage may vary.
So here’s where it stands. We have for your child high quality visual, auditory, and temporal models. The lip and teeth drawings are detailed, similar to the ones used to teach phonics in elementary classrooms via the “sound wall” approach. The side animations are as good as any found in professional articulation apps, and were made by a professional animator. The models are above and beyond what you would get in a printed kit, and you can generate them for any word you like. And crucially, your child can explore the models on their own, with their own interest, and in their own time.
Introduce. Repeat. Repeat. Wait for a flicker of interest to turn into something more.
Again, it is not proven. And I stress again, this is NOT a substitute for professional apraxia therapy.
But the learning materials are an option. And depending on what professionals are willing to do with your child, it may be the only option.
They have expertise, but you have time, all the time in the world.
And hey, maybe at the end of it they still won’t know how to talk. But they’ll know how to read. That would be helpful too!